‘I don’t trust her’: Stepdad refuses to let 22-year-old stepdaughter move in after she falsely accused his 20-year-old son of stealing her belongings, mom takes daughter's side

Author image for Bar Mor Hazut
Bar Mor Hazut • Senior Editor
May 26, 2025 7:00 PM EDT

When your single parent decides to tie the knot with someone new, and that someone also has children, it is an awkward situation, to say the least. Setting aside the fact that you now have another parental figure you barely even know, you also are 'given' new siblings, even though they are basically just strangers. Strangers who live under the same roof as you, have access to all your stuff, and are entitled to everything you are entitled to in regards to the family.

It makes sense if you don't feel like you can trust these practical strangers, even though they are technically your new family, However, it is much better for the family if nobody starts throwing accusations around that can damage the already fragile state of the family. That applies to the parents, whether they are the step or biological parents, the siblings, and everyone else who may be involved in the family. 

Advertisement

  • The father in the story below did not handle the coming together of his new family that well. He accused his son of stealing when his stepdaughter announced she had misplaced some of her belongings, then blamed her for his son's feelings of being mistreated. After she eventually found the misplaced items and proved the son did not have anything to do with it, her stepdad got upset that she didn't apologize to his son, and that led to a whole family dispute.

    Keep scrolling to read the full story.

  • 01
    Cheezburger Image 10509800704
    via Valerii Honcharuk

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • 02

    AITA for refusing to let my wife’s daughter move in after a past conflict with my son?

    I've been married to my wife, Laura, for about two years. We both have kids from previous relationships. I have a son [20M], Jake, who's in college.
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 03
    Laura has a daughter [22F], Emily, who just graduated and is currently job hunting. Last summer, Jake stayed with us for about six weeks between dorm leases. Emily was around
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 04
    a lot too, and honestly - it was tense. They didn't really get along. No big fights or anything, just a lot of awkward silence and weird energy. Emily made a few comments about
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 05
    the house feeling "crowded", and Jake mostly kept to himself. About a month in, Emily said she lost some cash and a pair of earbuds. She told Laura, who
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 06
    brought it to me. I confronted Jake about it - he got pretty upset, said he didn't take anything, and felt like he was being accused unfairly. Said it felt like he wasn't welcome. He
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 07
    ended up leaving early to stay with a friend. We barely talked for a while after that. A couple months later, Emily found the missing stuff in an old gym bag. Said it was
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 08
    probably just stress, a mistake. But she never actually apologized or took responsibility. No sorry, no real acknowledgment of what that put Jake through. I told Laura
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 09
    that it was messed up, and that Jake was hurt by it. She said she understood, but didn't want to push Emily. Now Emily wants to move in with us temporarily while she
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 10
    looks for work. Laura says it's fine and won't be for long. I said no. I don't trust the situation, and I don't want a repeat of last summer. Laura says I'm being harsh and
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 11
    holding a grudge. A few friends say I should let it go - that "family is family" and I should try to move on. But I feel stuck between keeping the peace in my
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 12
    marriage and protecting my son. Jake hasn't said much about it, but I know he still feels weird about what happened. And Emily's never really owned up to it.
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 13
    Cheezburger Image 10509800960
    via AntonioGuillem

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • 14
    Am I being unreasonable for saying no to her moving in? Or am I just trying to avoid another mess?
    via Famous-Language2543
  • 15
    Sorry-Thing7797 Did Emily accuse Jake? Or did she just state these things had gone missing and you assumed that your son must have taken them? Because that's how this reads.
    via Sorry-Thing7797
  • 16
    If she didn't accuse him, and it was you who just assumed that's what she was implying, then YTA for not allowing her to move back in.
    via Sorry-Thing7797
  • 17
    KllrDav YTA because of how you handled the OG accusation. I literally had a similar experience last night. My 16 year old had 8 friends sleep. over.
    via KllrDav
  • 18
    I couldn't find my keys, which had a Supreme multitool on the keychain. I called my son over and privately told him I couldn't find them, didn't want to
    via KllrDav
  • 19
    accuse anyone before he helped me look for them. We found them without falsely accusing anyone first.
    via KllrDav
  • 20
    Relevant-Reply3083 YTA from what you wrote it sounds like you're the problem not Emily. Emily didn't accuse your son of stealing anything you flew off the handle when
    via Relevant-Reply3083
  • 21
    your wife asked if you'd seen it and accused your own son. It sounds like the kids have a relationship typical of adult step siblings who aren't close.
    via Relevant-Reply3083
  • 22
    Inside-Grade-5025 YTA. People lose stuff. And what's more, she let you know when she found them. If this issue was this girl, she would not have told you. Also, this is her mother, and her home. A
    via Inside-Grade-5025
  • 23
    child who has just graduated, hasn't yet settled on where they will live and work. Her mother's home is hers, I honestly don't think you get to say no.
    via Inside-Grade-5025
  • 24
    Agreeable-Book-7018 YTA. For the fact that u automatically accused your son. People lose things all the time. Yet u went to theft. Or she did. Either way it will happen again. Ur not the Able for not letting her stay
    via Agreeable-Book-7018

Tags

family drama aita kids brother mother siblings stepchild reddit story parenting family sister stepdad Reddit parents children Father
Scroll Down For The Next Article